A.W. Tillinghast – Worldgolfer's Golf Course Reviews

Review: Baltusrol Golf Club (Lower)

February 16, 2026

The championship course at world-famous Baltusrol Golf Club, The Lower Course is a U.S. Open style parkland design with thick rough, phenomenal conditions, and many long par fours. Although limited aesthetically due to very flat terrain, this is a well-routed and well-bunkered course with tremendous history and prestige. I haven’t been here since the Gil Hanse restoration and hope to see the changes soon! … More Review: Baltusrol Golf Club (Lower)

Review: Wykagyl Country Club

November 17, 2025

A Ross/Tillinghast design characterized by small greens, wonderful rocky terrain, and old-school charm, Wykagyl is one of the best and most underrated courses in New York and a course absolutely worth seeing. … More Review: Wykagyl Country Club

Review: Bethpage State Park (Yellow Course)

January 22, 2025

Considered the easiest of the Bethpage courses, Bethpage Yellow was a pleasant surprise and offers some memorable holes and strong land movement at a great value. While it can’t compare to the Black or Red courses, it makes a strong push for 3rd best course at the complex and is worth a play. … More Review: Bethpage State Park (Yellow Course)

Review: Knollwood Country Club

October 4, 2024

A historic hidden gem in Westchester designed by the likes of Raynor, Tillinghast, and Banks, Knollwood features excellent bunkering and greens, plenty of quirk, and one of the best closers you’ll find anywhere. It is definitely underrated and is well-worth your time. … More Review: Knollwood Country Club

Review: Sleepy Hollow Country Club (Lower)

September 7, 2023

Sleepy Hollow members are fortunate to have this sporty 9-holer on property that features some original MacRaynor holes and is short and playable for the masses. Although not nearly as memorable or good as its world-class sister, I highly recommend an emergency nine here to get the full Sleepy experience. … More Review: Sleepy Hollow Country Club (Lower)

Review: Sleepy Hollow Country Club (Upper)

June 13, 2023

Newly rejuvenated by a landmark Gil Hanse renovation, Sleepy Hollow is once again one of the premier courses in America and is one of my absolute favorites. Golfers will love playing these fun template holes over a memorable and gorgeous terrain and an invite here is one to be savored. … More Review: Sleepy Hollow Country Club (Upper)

Review: Bethpage State Park (Green Course)

March 7, 2022

Although not on the same level as Bethpage Black or Red, Bethpage Green is a nice municipal course offering strong value, classic architecture, and an easier layout for all golfers to enjoy. It is worth a play in the area. … More Review: Bethpage State Park (Green Course)

Review: Orchard Hills Golf Course

July 7, 2021

In an area relatively devoid of good public options, Orchards Hills is a solid yet short 9 hole course in good condition but often too busy and expensive for repeat visits. … More Review: Orchard Hills Golf Course

Review: Bethpage State Park (Blue Course)

January 22, 2020

Although not nearly as dramatic or architecturally pure as Bethpage Black or Red, the Blue Course is another solid public offering at the legendary Bethpage State Park. The challenge, conditioning, and tremendous value make it a strong choice for those of all golfing abilities to enjoy on a regular basis. … More Review: Bethpage State Park (Blue Course)

Review: Philadelphia Cricket Club (Wissahickon Course)

November 12, 2018

The Wissahickon Course is the crown jewel of The Philadelphia Cricket Club and is one of the best courses not just in the Philadelphia area, but in the entire U.S. This Tillinghast gem is a classic U.S. Open-style course characterized by thick rough, speedy greens, and numerous long par fours full of character. This is a course I would enjoy playing every day and recommend very highly. … More Review: Philadelphia Cricket Club (Wissahickon Course)